- What is a Bitcoin Loan?
- How Getting a Bitcoin Loan Works
- Factors to Consider in Getting a Bitcoin Loan
- Custody Risk
- Insurance on Bitcoin Loans
- Origination Fees
- Interest Rate: What is the APR?
- Loan to Value Requirement
- Loan to Value (LTV) Vs Collateral to Principal (CTP)
- Prepayment Penalties
- Logistics/Token Requirements
- Tax Implications
- Loan Maturity
- What happens if the price of Bitcoin increases during the loan?
- What happens if the price of bitcoin drops during the loan?
- Common Bitcoin Loan Purposes
While you hold bitcoin because you believe it will increase in value, there may come a time when it makes financial sense to access US Dollars from your bitcoin savings. Unfortunately, selling bitcoin in certain countries incurs capital gains taxes. For those looking to avoid selling their bitcoin, bitcoin loans are an option to get dollars today without making a sale.
Bitcoin-backed US dollar loans may be a good option for those who have held bitcoin long-term, have a relatively low tax basis, and need access to dollars. As bitcoin becomes a larger share of an individual’s overall assets, many holders would like to improve their lives by accessing the liquidity from bitcoin gains. Unfortunately, much of the legacy financial system still does not recognize bitcoin as a viable asset for many financial services. This is where Unchained Capital can assist with a bitcoin loan.
Unchained Capital began issuing bitcoin loans in 2017. A bitcoin loan allows bitcoin holders to use their bitcoin as collateral to take out a loan in U.S. dollars, without missing out on the potential long-term gains of holding bitcoin.
In this article, we’d like to share some information about how bitcoin loans work and who should use them. We’ll also address common questions or misunderstandings.
What is a Bitcoin Loan?
A bitcoin loan is a collateralized US Dollar loan backed by bitcoin. At Unchained Capital, this involves sending bitcoin to a dedicated multisignature address. Once the bitcoin is confirmed on the blockchain, US Dollars are sent to a client’s bank account and interest on the loan is paid monthly.
How Getting a Bitcoin Loan Works
Bitcoin loans are similar to traditional secured loans except they use bitcoin as collateral and eliminate the need for credit checks. To set up a loan, you create an account, complete onboarding, and submit a loan application. We provide you with loan agreements, and once they are signed, we provide you with a bitcoin address for depositing the loan collateral. You send your bitcoin to the address provided. Once we confirm receipt, we fund your loan by disbursing US dollars to your bank account the next business day. Interest payments are due once per month until loan maturity. This process typically takes 1-2 business days from account creation to the deposit in your bank account.
Factors to Consider in Getting a Bitcoin Loan
Here are a few important factors to consider before taking out a bitcoin loan.
Bitcoin is a “bearer instrument.” Whoever controls the private keys to the bitcoin, controls that bitcoin. As many exchange hacks over the years have taught us, there is no guarantee that a custodian won’t lose your bitcoin.
This means it is extremely important to understand where and how your bitcoin is stored. Be sure to ask any bitcoin loan provider how the bitcoin will be secured.
At Unchained Capital, we believe you should have the maximum control and transparency possible. When you take out a loan, you can hold 1 of 3 keys, which ensures that your assets are segregated in a dedicated multisignature address, and that the assets remain in your title. This also means that Unchained Capital is unable to lend out your collateral to others for additional yield (a process commonly referred to as rehypothecation).
In this way, we minimize the counterparty risk for the custody of your bitcoin and eliminate the possibility of socialized losses, which is a common occurrence for losses from rehypothecated trades.
Here’s how Unchained custody works:
- You provide one of the keys used to generate the multisignature address for your loan.
- Unchained Capital holds another key, and the third is held by a third-party key agent, Citadel SPV. Citadel SPV specializes in strong financial controls including corporate governance, administration and accounting.
- All transactions require 2-of-3 parties to sign. You can collaborate with Unchained or Citadel SPV to sign transactions.
- All parties must use an offline hardware wallet (Trezor, Ledger and Coldcard are currently supported) to provide keys and sign transactions.
Unchained’s multi-institution 2-of-3 model significantly enhances security for all involved. No one person or organization can threaten the collateral. This provides enhanced controls for several scenarios:
- In collateral liquidation events, Citadel SPV will confirm through out-of-band communication prior to signing any transactions.
- If Unchained ever fails to perform its contractual obligations, Citadel SPV will work with customers to release collateral if necessary.
- Citadel SPV provides a backup to either the customer or Unchained in the rare event that a key has become lost or compromised.
Rehypothecation is a practice where banks and brokers lend client assets that have been posted as collateral. By doing so, client assets are put at risk and the bank (or broker) earns interest by re-lending client assets. In the case of bitcoin loans, many bitcoin loan providers take their clients’ bitcoin, which serves as collateral to a dollar denominated loan, and lend those assets out to third parties.
As a part of this process, the bitcoin loan provider is earning interest from both the interest payments of the borrower and the proceeds of lending the borrower’s collateral to others. The lender will often pass a portion of this interest on to the borrower of dollars in the form of a marginally lower rate of interest, but all or a portion of the borrower’s collateral has been put at risk. Many borrowers are unaware of this risk, and it is rarely discussed or disclosed prominently. Through rehypothecation of collateral, a borrower of dollars is being exposed to multiple layers of counterparty risk.
Working with a lender that is rehypothecating means putting your bitcoin at risk. Ultimately, you should make an assessment of not only the credit risk of the lender but also the credit risk of the borrowers to which the lender is lending the rehypothecated collateral. By using a lender who rehypothes collateral, you are accepting the risk that either the lender or the borrower of rehypothecated collateral becomes insolvent, leading, most likely, to socialized losses.
At Unchained Capital, we do not rehypothecate collateral, eliminating this risk. Further, we allow you to hold 1 of the 3 keys to your collateral account, which gives you the ability to prove cryptographically that the your bitcoin is stored in a dedicated address at all times and has not been rehypothecated.
A key reason borrowers take loans from Unchained Capital is to preserve their bitcoin. The structure and security of our loans minimizes counterparty risk and prevents any potential losses from being socialized.
When bitcoin lending companies rehypothecate, they often pool client funds and lend them out to short sellers and market makers. If a trade leads to losses, in many cases, all clients will be affected, since the bitcoin has been pooled.
Unchained Capital provides borrowers assurance that their collateral is secure and auditable on-chain. Our rates may seem higher, but our rates are usually lower when adjusting for risk.
If bitcoin is the future global reserve currency, why would it make sense to cut corners to save a small amount on the interest? The risk of losing the bitcoin forever is far too great. If bitcoin is ever re-lent through rehypothecation arrangements, the risk of principal loss is greater. If preserving your bitcoin is a reason for using a loan rather than just selling, taking that risk defeats the purpose of the loan.
Unchained Capital generally lends at 40% LTV. Unlike many other companies, since we do not rehypothecate, we are less sensitive to collateral increases. For lenders that do rehypothecate, higher LTV rates of 20% or 35% represent additional bitcoin that can be lent out to achieve a higher return. So, such lenders put more borrower bitcoin at risk via rehypothecation.
At Unchained Capital, our most important considerations are maintaining our customer relationships and securing our customers’ bitcoin. With this focus, we’ve never been tempted to increase our customers’ risk to improve our profits or lower our rates. We believe we’ve made the correct decision for our loan product: no rehypothecation and a serious dedication to security.
Insurance on Bitcoin Loans
Many bitcoin companies advertise that bitcoin collateral is insured. There are a few questions to ask a loan provider to identify what is exactly covered by insurance. Since bitcoin is a bearer asset and transactions are irreversible, insurance can be very tricky and often doesn’t provide adequate coverage. Holding private keys is generally the best insurance in bitcoin.
- Is rehypothecated collateral insured for loss?
- What percent of total funds are covered by insurance? Is it only the hot wallet funds or are cold-stored funds also covered?
- What types of loss are covered?
- Does the insurance pay users back in bitcoin or the value of the bitcoin at the time of a loss?
- Does the insurance provided by a third-party custodian cover any hacks or internal comprises which may occur on the side of a lending counterparty?
These questions are extremely important to ask and are usually not covered adequately by insurance. A new currency like bitcoin comes with an entirely new security paradigm that can’t be duplicated using the same tools from the existing system, which is why Unchained Capital believes that private key ownership is the safest way to offer financial services.
For Bitcoin loans, origination fees are the fees paid to initiate the loan. This is a one-time fee that is paid up front and deducted from the loan amount. At Unchained Capital, the origination fee depends on the duration of the loan.
Some lenders will add an origination fee on top of the loan amount. For example, using $10,000 as a loan amount requested, they will deposit $10,000 into the client’s bank account and charge them a $100 origination fee. In this case the loan amount will be $10,100. Other lenders, such as Unchained Capital, deduct the origination fee from the loan amount requested, meaning if a client requests $10,000, $9,900 is deposited into their bank account and the $100 origination fee is deducted from the amount requested.
Interest Rate: What is the APR?
The APR is the total cost of the loan expressed as an annual rate, and the formula in the United States is mandated by the Truth in Lending Act. Below is an example of how the term, interest rate, origination fee, and principal are used to determine the APR of a loan in the United States. Note the below interest rates, origination fees, and APRs are by way of example only and do not reflect Unchained’s actual current interest rates and fees.
|Term in Month||Interest Rate||Origination Fee||Principal||APR||Total Cost of the Loan if held for 1 year|
The APR normalizes the rates of a loan assuming the loan is renewed for a total term of 1 year. In the example above, the 3-month loan would have been renewed 3 times. The total cost is higher than the 12-month loan because the origination fee must be paid each time a borrower chooses to renew.
Many lending companies will offer a lower interest rate but with a higher origination fee. As demonstrated below, this causes the APR to increase substantially and ultimately means the loans are more expensive for the borrower.
|Term in Month||Interest Rate||Origination Fee||Principal||APR||Total Cost of the Loan if held for 1 year|
Shorter term loans will advertise lower interest rates, but keep in mind the origination fee. If a client were to take a 3-month loan with a 1% origination fee, and then the client chose to renew the loan, the client could end up spending more annually than if they were to take a 12-month loan at a slightly higher interest rate with a single origination fee.
Loan to Value Requirement
The loan to value requirement is an important metric to consider when taking a bitcoin-backed loan. At 40% LTV, this means that a $10,000 loan requires $25,000 of bitcoin used as collateral. This ratio helps prevent collateral liquidations during normal market price fluctuations.
Other companies offer lower interest rates at lower LTV ratios (eg 20%, 30%). This means that their clients are depositing far more bitcoin. Some companies do this so they can then rehypothecate (lend out) the collateral to those interested in borrowing bitcoin, and other companies ask for lower LTV because it is lower risk for the companies to lend since they have more collateral. Unchained Capital loans are issued at 40% LTV because we do not rehypothecate, and we want to avoid liquidations as much as possible.
Loan to Value (LTV) Vs Collateral to Principal (CTP)
The collateral to principal ratio is the inverse of the loan to value ratio. A 40% LTV means that you have a CTP of 250%. The CTP ratio makes it easier for Unchained Capital clients to understand the current status of their collateral ratio, especially during a drop in the price of bitcoin.
Many traditional loans contain prepayment penalties, meaning that clients incur a charge for repaying a loan before the maturity date.
Unchained Capital loans are allowed to be prepaid without penalty, so clients are free to end loans early at no additional cost. If clients repay the loan early, the only cost incurred for the loan will be the origination fee plus interest for the period during which the funds were utilized and outstanding. Once the principal balance has been repaid, the remaining interest payments are voided and the rest of the collateral will be returned.
Many bitcoin lending companies have created their own currency, which can be used to make interest payments or used as interest payments when customers lend them other currencies, such as bitcoin or stablecoins. To end users, this generally looks like a good deal, as the interest they pay is lower, and the interest they earn is higher for lending out bitcoin. This system is possible for a few reasons.
- The companies control the supply of their proprietary currency, and can debase it
- The companies are rehypothecating collateral or lent BTC while they pay interest in their own currency, which can be debased.
All of these reasons appear beneficial on the surface, but they are hiding the risks associated with lending out bitcoin or taking a loan in bitcoin.
This system works well until it doesn’t. If the value of their token crashes, clients can be left holding less valuable tokens while their bitcoin has been lost. Remember: Not your keys, not your bitcoin.
Unchained Capital does not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. Due to the complexity of tax law and changing legislation, you should consult with your tax professional regarding your specific circumstance. The information contained below is for informational purposes only and does not constitute tax advice.
What are my tax liabilities when taking out a loan backed by my bitcoin?
In traditional lending, if using an asset like a home as collateral for a loan, the IRS does not claim that the asset has been “sold,” so the home owners are not subject to capital gains that a sale might trigger.
Taking out a loan is usually “tax neutral” with respect to the collateral. Even if the value of the home has increased, using it as collateral for a loan is not a “sale,” and therefore clients are not required to pay capital gains taxes at the time of the loan.
In the crypto lending space, the IRS has not given explicit guidance, but the treatment of crypto-backed loans will likely be analogous to traditional lending. In March 2014, the IRS stated that virtual currencies should be treated as property for tax purposes.
As with traditional lending, the use of property as collateral should not be considered a sale. Therefore, borrowing against cryptocurrency should not trigger capital gains taxes.
Are loan interest payments tax-deductible?
The IRS has yet to issue specific guidance surrounding interest payments in crypto lending. However, we can begin to get a better idea for how they may be treated by once again looking at traditional lending. To understand whether interest payments are tax-deductible, it is necessary to consider whether a loan is used for personal, investment, or business-related purposes.
If a business takes out a loan for a commercial purpose, the interest is typically treated as a legitimate tax-deductible business expense.
If a loan is taken out for personal reasons, interest expense is usually not considered tax-deductible. However, if an individual borrows money to purchase a piece of real estate that will produce investment income, the interest they pay on their loan may be considered investment interest expense, which may be tax-deductible.
For more information on whether an investment interest expense is tax deductible, you should consult with a tax professional or look at this article.
What are the tax implications if Unchained sells my collateral, such as during a margin call?
During a margin call, borrowers can choose to either deposit additional collateral or pay down their principal to re-adjust their loan-to-value ratio to required levels.
In the rare case of a liquidation event, which occurs when a borrower has not been able to deposit additional collateral or complete the transactions necessary to repay principal, margin call and/or the value of their bitcoin collateral falls to a collateral-to-principal ratio of 110%, Unchained would be forced to foreclose and sell bitcoin on behalf of the borrower to recover the amount owed on the loan. This would be treated as a property sale for income tax purposes, and clients may be liable for capital gains tax based on the sale price (and value).
At the end of the term of the loan, a few options are available to pay off the loan.
- A loan can be rolled over to a new loan. The new loan pays off the current loan, and the collateral is transferred to the new loan. The terms of the new loan depend on market conditions, and may have changed since the original loan.
- A USD payment can be made for the outstanding principal amount of the loan plus the final interest payment.
- A combination of a USD payment for part of the outstanding principal balance of the loan amount with the remainder rolled over to a new loan.
- In the event the price has increased, then a rollover with additional funding may be available.
- Clients can also request at the end of the term of a loan that Unchained liquidate a certain percentage of collateral necessary to repay the loan rather than make a USD payment.
- When a loan is ultimately repaid, Unchained will then return collateral to clients.
One consideration in a rollover is the LTV may need to be at 40% at the time of origination on the new loan. If the price has decreased then additional collateral may be required for the new loan.
What happens if the price of Bitcoin increases during the loan?
Some lenders allow excess collateral to be refunded and returned to the client to an address which is fully under a client’s control.
If the Bitcoin price increases so that the CTP ratio exceeds 300%, the borrower can withdraw collateral until the CTP ratio is back to the original 250%. Collateral refunds are supported once per month, although it is a good practice to keep extra collateral in the event that the price of bitcoin drops. The borrower can move the refunded bitcoin into a multisignature vault address where they hold 2-of-3 keys, or into another bitcoin address of their choosing.
What happens if the price of bitcoin drops during the loan?
Bitcoin is a volatile asset, so the CTP of a loan constantly fluctuates. Lenders set loan terms to adjust for these price fluctuations, but at some point, if bitcoin drops too far, borrowers will need to post additional collateral or pay off part of the loan’s principal as part of a margin call. A margin call means that action must be taken in order to get the loan back to a required collateral position.
For an Unchained Capital loan, the margin call process begins at 150% CTP. In the event the CTP ratio of a loan hits 150%, borrowers must either deposit additional bitcoin collateral or fund a partial repayment of the loan principal to improve the CTP ratio.
If the price of bitcoin drops further and causes the loan to decrease to a CTP ratio of 135%, the time to respond to the margin call is accelerated. Borrowers then have 4 hours to either deposit additional bitcoin collateral or fund a partial repayment of the loan principal to improve the CTP ratio.
Finally, in the most extreme bitcoin price drops, Unchained Capital must immediately liquidate loans at 110% CTP. This is the worst case scenario, but we must follow this rule without exception to ensure that Unchained can continue to lend to clients in the future.
Traditional banking limitations can cause delayed deposits, particularly when trying to make principal payments over holidays and weekends or after traditional banking hours. The ability to respond by sending bitcoin collateral is critical and is the best way to respond when traditional banking is unavailable.
We never want to see loans liquidated, so we do our best to work with clients through the margin call process by presenting options to maintain the CTP ratio at required levels. An Unchained Capital Vault provides an easy option to transfer bitcoin quickly into a loan collateral address during margin calls.
Common Bitcoin Loan Purposes
Getting a loan allows clients to access dollars from their bitcoin today without having to sell and incur capital gains tax or reduce exposure to bitcoin price increases. Taking a loan during a bitcoin bull market can be a good way to access dollars without missing the gains from bitcoin’s increase in value.
Here are some of the most common reasons people take out bitcoin-backed loans.
Buy a House
Many long-term bitcoin holders want to diversify their portfolios into real estate. Investors may be considering buying a home to use personally or as a cash flow rental property. Similarly, existing real estate owners may want to remodel or to make improvements to existing properties.
However, a significant tax liability or desire to hold a long-term bitcoin position may prevent one from cashing out. A bitcoin loan is an option to get access to cash needed for a real estate purchase without missing out on future appreciation.
One of the most common methods for bitcoin traders to take leveraged positions is to use existing bitcoin as collateral for a loan and use the dollars to purchase more bitcoin. Leverage can be an effective tool to increase returns during bull markets.
That said, leverage can also be very risky. Many believe that just holding bitcoin is risky due to its extreme volatility. If traders leverage bitcoin with a collateralized loan and the price of bitcoin crashes, the collateral could be liquidated to cover the loan principal. At Unchained Capital, margin calls start at 150% collateral-to-principal ratio, with accelerated margin calls at 135% and liquidation at 110%.
In the event of a rapid price crash, clients who cannot post additional collateral or make principal payments in time, can be left with a small fraction of the original bitcoin collateral. If they have taken out loans in order to leverage their bitcoin, they could be left with fewer bitcoin than they started with if the market goes in the wrong direction. Keep these risks in mind when thinking about leverage.
Many bitcoin investors are also entrepreneurs and small business owners.
A strategic loan on bitcoin holdings can allow corporations to
- fund expansion
- free up working capital
- consolidate high-interest-rate debt
A strategic business loan paired with a client-controlled vault gives a business total control over their BTC, and flexibility with how they leverage company holdings. With the Unchained Capital Enterprise suite, you get access to accounting documents to track your bitcoin flow, multiple users with different permissions, the ability to purchase bitcoin OTC, and quick access to USD.
Unchained Capital is the only bitcoin-native financial services company that gives businesses and individuals control over private keys, which is why our business suite delivers the highest level of security in the industry.
Businesses also deserve to hold their private keys and to have access to financial services, but the needs of a business are different than the needs of an individual.
Why would I take a bitcoin loan instead of selling my bitcoin?
To answer this question, we consulted with Daniel Winters of Global Tax, LLC.
“Crypto investors have unique challenges concerning their taxes, especially long time investors that have large paper gains. For an early investor interested in generating USD from their assets, selling it at the long term capital gains rate seems an obvious choice.
However, that’s not always the best decision. At higher income levels, the federal long term capital gains rate is 20%, plus an additional 3.8% for a total of 23.8%. When you add state income taxes, the total tax hit can easily reach 30% or higher. In this scenario, an investor with $1,000,000 in long term capital gains may end up with only $700,000 after taxes. In essence, the investor has a 30% cost of capital to cash out to USD.
If appropriate tax planning isn’t done, the investor may actually need to sell additional crypto assets to cover the USD taxes due on the original capital gain. Now, the investor has even more tax to pay, because they have new capital gains from selling crypto to pay the taxes on the original sale.
One alternative is taking out a bitcoin-backed loan. Borrowing against crypto assets is usually NOT a sale, thus no tax is usually due on the transaction. The investor can therefore potentially borrow USD against their crypto, continue to hold their bitcoin, and pay less in interest than the taxes on the capital gains.”
Bitcoin mining is extremely resource intensive, demanding large electricity purchases, equipment purchases and constant equipment maintenance. These expenses typically must be paid in a fiat currency. As a result, miners sell much of the freshly mined bitcoin to cover these costs.
Bitcoin loans offer an alternative to selling bitcoin to cover these expenses. With a collateralized loan, miners can access the dollars they need to cover their costs, while still capturing the gains from the bitcoin that they earned.
A bitcoin loan combined with other financial services, such as bitcoin custody, buying and selling, and futures contracts, give miners many different options to hedge risks if the mining landscape becomes more competitive, or if the price of bitcoin crashes making it temporarily unprofitable to mine.
Increasing the number of available derivative markets and financial options for miners helps to grow the bitcoin ecosystem by allowing the mining industry to weather short-term shocks.
With an Unchained Capital business account, mining companies can secure their own bitcoin in a 2-of-3 multisignature address where they hold a majority of the keys, can make OTC bitcoin trades, and can access USD using their bitcoin as collateral. Unchained Capital is becoming the one-stop shop for bitcoin-native financial services.
We hope that this guide has answered your most pertinent questions about bitcoin loans. It has been a pleasure to serve the bitcoin community for their custody and lending needs, and we look forward to assisting more bitcoiners on their journey in the future.
Our team of loan experts is happy to help with any additional questions you may have. You can schedule time to speak with our Loans Operations team here, or create an Unchained Capital account and apply for a loan today.